This is something we did a little bit on OPF that I think would be cool to bring back here, provided people are interested?
Basically, we'll open up a thread that has a One Piece related debate topic in (e.g. is Zoro the Perfect Vice Captain?), and users will debate either for or against that question. Each debate lasts two weeks, and at the end we could even have a vote and see whose arguments we thought were the best presented. We could also do a "team" type thing, where users team up to debate and work together to make an argument.
Would this be something you guys would take part in?