>
Still, do I think mantra is foresight + area awareness, etc? Of course not, that would be contradictory to the theory itself.
I need a minor clarification here, so I'm quoting this directly. What theory are you referencing here? We have sooooo much overlap at this point, this makes a big difference.
My context is that we are just discussing "One Piece connectivity/believability" with this tangent. Other theories should be kept out for simplicity. I will only use terminology to convey bridged concepts, but I'm 100% only going on big picture stuff here (and excluding any of my personal theory biases => excluding stuff I think is proven with layers and layers of tons and tons of implied context/direct context ). So yes, there is this gray area, but it's reading like we bridged most of these, so I'm fine running with all tangents given we establish clear context.>
Yeah, aura visualization is a basic application and I still think it's the closest think we'll get to "advanced" kenbunshoku as far as mantra goes. Well, perhaps an improvement on it would be for experienced mantra users to be capable of seeing their target as clear as if they were next to them instead of just as aura figures. Still, do I think mantra is foresight + area awareness, etc? Of course not, that would be contradictory to the theory itself. Predicting your opponents next move vaguely (kick to the middle right) is one of kenbunshoku haki's abilities in general. Whether it's mantra or foresight, both can do it. The difference is, foresight does it better. Foresight allows the user to see further into the future and see the target's future actions with even better clarity.
Mantra on the other hand sacrifices that kind of foresight in favor of increased range. This brings us back to the building example. Can someone be both a tall and a wide building? Absolutely. But that's only if they're talented and train both types of kenbunshoku. For most users who can't spare talent or time to train both and have to pick on, it's usually based on their fighting style. Close combat fighters benefit more from foresight and snipers benefit more from mantra.
I'm quoting this as a whole because based on the second paragraph, we 100% agree. So I'm a bit confused on where the lingering discrepancy leading to the comments in the first paragraph stem from.>
If you want to suggest that kenbunshoku is one dimensional and its progress it something akin to: basic kenbunshoku -> foresight -> mantra, of course I have nothing against it. But based on its abilities, I view kenbunshoku as something two dimensional, hence why I made a theory to properly point out said two dimensions. I suppose this is something we'll have to agree to disagree on.
I definitely 100% disagree on the first sentence. HOWEVER...I'm going to willingly complicate this and say that I partially disagree with the second aspect. I'm literally brain farting on the theory being referenced here is, but just the title will suffice assuming this is the theory per my first question.
I visualize a venn diagram for Kenbunshoku. Everything is a spectrum and the truly gifted kenbunshoku users (Shanks, Fujitora...and SANJI...so that's what the main power up was supposed to be...that explains Oda's willingness to screw Sanji over so much => this is actually worth a separate theory...eventually and I'm losing track of all the other good ideas but oh well) will master all of them and thus be overpowered fighters (they can make up for ASTRONOMICAL differences in other category/possibly multiple categories of combat capabilities). This 100% fits Shanks being a normal sized human WITHOUT a fruit ability and without a second arm.
Based on my bias of the jump to Yonkou/admiral level, adding mantra to someone with foresight kenbunshoku changes nothing realistically. It is only the jump to mastered kenbunshoku that matters. If we are going with numbers: foresight kenbunshoku is 80.0 (the jump from anyone in the 70's). Mantra might only be as small as 81 or even 80.5. Maybe it's 82-83, but context doesn't support this in my mind. What matters is the consistency.>
I still don't see what someone's "level" have to do with this. As far as I know, a high level of strength in the One Piece world doesn't boost someone's brain capacity. Enel's brain capacity was boosted thanks to his devil fruit, it wasn't his haki or any other part of his skill set.
Let's try this a different way: what part of Enel was smart, strategic, etc.? My bias is nothing. If Enel has "boosted brain capacity" there should be a second or third aspect of being "smart".
So if anything, only being good at mantra CONTRADICTS the brain capacity boost to me because it implies Enel is ONLY a mantra specialist/protege at mantra. This isn't big enough for a tag, but a couple extra spacing should be good enough.
>
people at Skypiea do and say. Aisa's range is certainly impressive, considering her age and lack of haki training but that has to do purely with kenbunshoku. Actively monitoring what almost everyone on an entire island is saying, all the time, is something only Enel has been show to be capable of so far.
Umm...Aisa does the EXACT same things as Enel. She is shown to "read people's minds" when her ability is first shown. There's even a gag on her reading Luffy's mind. Aisa and Enel have the EXACT same level of mantra capabilities.
I will give a little in the sense that I 100% agree that Aisa is implied to not be as quick to screen through the entire island and cannot quickly focus on a desired target. I.E. I would 100% put Enel at a higher rating of kenbunshoku than Aisa. He would be much higher since he is implied to be much more consistent and proficient. That part I 100% agree on.
I will reference Enel's extremely lazy side. Context contradicts Enel 100%, "all the time" using his mantra. This implies Enel has "Yonkou/admiral levels" of "haki energy". This reminds me of Jawa and Marco thinking there was "unlimited" logia energy. Kenbunshoku should take less "haki energy" than busoushoku, but that is only for "basic" techniques. Context implies there is a dramatic jump in usage for advanced techniques (and an astronomical jump for mastered techniques). Thus, Enel only has to pay attention when he feels a group of Shandians getting riled up. Ah, actually any group, but he has the Skypeians under his thumb, so he can almost fully ignore them (and thus he had the military underlings forcing his "peace" on them). So even more so...Enel isn't even paying attention to the vast majority of the island. This is why Nami goes unnoticed. Enel is NOT an expert/master. So there, there is even proof to directly contradict the 100% usage. All breadcrumbs only point in one direction. >
Why just 9? Sure, the strongest 9 go to his devision captains. But he could get as many devil fruits as he wants and give them to lower ranked underlings. Or rather, with him having taken Whitebeard's place, it wouldn't be too surprising for him to add more divisions, and in turn division captains, to his fleet. Sure, the "core" group will most likely end up being the same number as the strawhats at the time of the fight but Whitebeard had division captains with considerably lower strength than the high ranked ones as well. Well, it can be either, it doesn't really matter. Either way, there's nothing limiting Teach's hunt to 9 fruits.
I stated 9 for the "core" aspect. Even if it is for the entire crew, Blackbeard runs into Kaidou's problem. Context implies legit New World powerhouses already have a fruit ability. It is the exception to not have a fruit ability. Having a weakling eat a devil fruit is pointless since they cannot harm a legit powerhouse without haki.
No matter what, context is already limiting who the ability hunt is for. Oda has purposefully kept both options available, but the context behind how and why it is happening (the ability hunt) is very rigid.>
Side note: Shiryuu's devil fruit choice really was a let down. Personally I liek the limiting factor you have suggested for awakening before, time. But maybe Oda will make it so Teach used some uncommon methods to help awaken his own and his division captains' fruit abilities and the suke suke no mi will be able to hide even from kenbunshoku users. I can't really say anything about it right now but it really was a letdown.
This (referencing awakenings only) breaks connectivity/believability. A primary aspect/requirement of an awakening (was at least, but can't be certain now with B.S.) is/was time/duration of having the fruit ability. Even Zoro is struggling to get close to Yonkou/admiral level. Level 6 was full of the "runners-up to Roger and Whitebeard". So if someone of THAT power level DIDN'T have a fruit ability...giving them an awakening kills the plot. Either they cannot legitimately keep up with Roger/Whitebeard or they are now WAAAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYY too strong for Usopp, Nami, Chopper, and even moderate/somewhat legitimate fighters like Brook, Franky, and maybe even Robin.
I'm 100% convinced the relatively minor B.S. at the time (I'm forgetting exactly where in the manga plot we see Shiryuu using the suke suke abilities, but it 100% is before the super bad B.S.) is why we have this mistake. Oda runs with the B.S. he establishes and that is the reality of our current predicament with the manga. The five year plan and ALL of the "original plan" (the stuff Oda discussed with WAVES of editors over 10-20 years) 10-billion percent does not have such guaranteed mistakes. B.S. is B.S. because of the previous levels of literary perfection. >
For starters, like I siad previously, I mentioned Wapol not for his strength but for his fruit's ability to produce the metal Franky used to make Franky shogun. Teach seemingy doesn't have someone to utilize it the same way as Franky (although he'd still be able to use it as top tier metal) but what about the World Government / Marines? They have the person who made the blueprints Franky gained inspiration from. If Vegapunk had access to an unlimited amount of free Wapometal, the sky would be the limit. So if stealing devil fruits was so easy, why would the world government not simply steal Wapol's devil fruit? He's weak so its should be a piece of cake, and I don't think they'd care much about what his country would think. They wouldn't even know who would have killed him anyway.
I think you are giving Wapol WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYY too much credit for the Franky Shogun overlap. The main property is the ability to reform/reshape (the TOY aspect). The Government is not THAT stupid. They have better strategies (big picture/war strategies) than even Big Mom, Kaidou, and technically even Blackbeard's "perfect plan". Context for my bias is that Wapolmetal is weak, and it is ONLY the Vegapunk level technology that allows for the durability of Franky Shogun. Franky already has basic blacksmithing abilities since this overlaps his skills as a shipwright. Mixing two alloys is very basic to me.
There is 100% a "magical" aspect from the gag devil fruit ability (that 100% matches the gag character). Context. Everything in the right context. So I have a very hard time seeing any legitimacy for gag characters. The biggest example is Buggy, and he only has it because he is Oda's favorite character. Wapol will have some sort of "role" in the final war, but it will be for gag purposes only.
So I'm definitely down to follow this tangent. This directly overlaps with the Enel aspect in terms of relevance to the plot and specifically their specific point in the plot (Enel WILL be 100% relevant and massively powered up based on the massive cover story that directly ties to the origins of the Ancient Kingdom). >
Putting that aside, I think you're fosucing too much on "strong" devil fruits. Much like Lucci said back at Enies Lobby, it depends on how you use the devil fruit's power and the chance of someone weakening from eating one (if there is such a thing even) is low. And since with devil fruit hunting, you'd know which power you'dbe getting, such a chance is nonexistant. Getting even the most seemingly weak of devil fruits would help a fighter of any level. Sure, it'd be weaker than top tier devil fruits but any ability is better than no ability.
Then this contradicts the "perfect plan" of Blackbeard/potentially Xebec by your preferences.
If we want to use pure strategy with zero One Piece context, yes, clearly the strongest "crew" is the one with the most fruit abilities (which is why the Marines are the strongest). Blackbeard COULD try this, but at a certain point, he gets the attention of the Marines/Government and they specifically target him. He has CONSTANTLY avoided unnecessary attention and only moves when the time is right. So in my mind, even this explains why it cannot be a "take any and all fruit abilities". Burgess doesn't comment on wanting Robin's ability (which is potentially top 25, and especially with what her next power up is). He only comments on wanting Luffy's gomu gomu ability. I think there is tons of context for specificity in the ability hunt. And B.S. is B.S. with only one exception...so far.>
As for the supernovas, I think Kaido just gets a kick out of breaking people's will is all. If they submit it's fine, but if they don't, having someone else eat their fruit would be better than not getting the ability at all. The point stands though, many people would be hunting for devil fruits. Both Big Mom and Kaido along with Teach, the world government and there would even probably be independent devil fruit hunters with specific kairoseki equipment. If devil fruit hunting was as simple as "going to the nearest fruit" anyway. Personally, I think it's not so simple and I suggest such in the Brook theory.
Ah...maybe this helps: yes. Obviously the strategy (that can only happen with taking away One Piece context) of having the most fruit abilities is the most logical. My point in all of this is that there is already context to contradict this from being possible and hopefully the above does this. Especially with the Government's new power, taking down Blackbeard is not a problem. >
Like I say in the Brook theory, the devil has control over the dead user's soul and can choose ANY fruit to "reincarnate" into
I'm biased to say this had to be either in the midst of a paragraph that had an opening sentence of a different topic/implication, or it wasn't mentioned. Either way...I'm super biased to just say facade of complexity. And all of the above should be at the bare minimum the starting point of being the "theory killer" on the "sexy" option. This is the reality of how One Piece works and it ONLY works because all breadcrumbs only point in one direction. There is not universal acceptance without literary perfection. Oda has earned universal acceptance, but as B.S. piles up, it will be steadily lost. Oda's stupidity to run with B.S. is why permanently ruining the series is a guarantee. It only doesn't happen if Oda changes and that is extremely unlikely based on even his main apology being completely half-assed and reeking of being forced to do it. >
Honestly, Kaido's biggest plot armor in this regard is the kick he gets out of breaking people's wills. If it wasn't for that, giving the ability even to a waiter would be better than not getting it at all. Still, this isn't a plot hole regarding only Kaido. Big Mom could hunt for devil fruit, the world government could hunt for devil fruits. Random people could hunt for devil fruits. If stealing them was so simple, they wouldn't be as rare as they've been introduced to be. Well, that's just my opinion.
I'm running with the tangent because I've already posted part of the Kaidou context previously.
Rarity is based on location. All comments on rarity are in the Blues and the beginning of the Grand Line only.